Tool comparisons
AEO Action vs AthenaHQ: credits, or a flat department.
AthenaHQ builds and publishes, and its list of CMS connections is longer than ours. So this page argues the thing that actually separates us — one credit pool for everything versus a flat price — with the math laid out for you to run yourself.
Updated 2026-11-11 · Prices and data verified 2026-11-10
AthenaHQ is the closest thing AEO Action has to a real rival on execution — it recommends, writes, and publishes to a connected CMS, not just watches — and this page says so in its first sentence rather than its last. What actually separates the two products is the billing model. AthenaHQ sells a credit allowance: free at 300 credits, $295/month at 3,600, with monitoring and content work drawing on the same pool. AEO Action sells a flat department from $149/month: daily 100-question scans, one prepared artifact a day, approve-to-published, index submission, dated receipts — the same invoice no matter how hard the loop runs.
The concession up front: they build and publish
In the neutral one-liner from our dataset, AthenaHQ is: Y Combinator-backed GEO platform founded by ex-Google Search PMs; credit-metered tracking with recommendation and content agents that publish to a connected CMS. Many tools in this category stop at the dashboard; AthenaHQ does not. Our note on what it does after the diagnosis reads: A real execution loop: recommendations, a content optimization agent, and eight documented Create & Publish connections (Shopify, Webflow, Wix, Framer, WordPress, Payload CMS, Sanity, Contentful) that publish content created in Athena to the live site. Squarespace is not on the list. Everything draws on the same credit pool as monitoring. Read that list twice if your site is on Webflow, Wix, Shopify, or Framer: on those builders its connections put the content inside your own CMS, which is further than our product goes there. 2026 reviews also credit it with a rare feature — hallucination detection, catching false AI claims about a brand — and its engine list is long: 11 models on the $295 Starter plan: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, Copilot, Grok, DeepSeek, Meta AI, and Mistral. The free Essential plan covers 5 (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Gemini, Copilot). Where the market splits into watchers and doers — mapped tool by tool in the best AI visibility tools — AthenaHQ sits on the doing side. That is exactly why the meter matters.
How a credit month actually runs down
AthenaHQ's plans page now opens with a free plan, and it deserves a fair reading: Essential includes 300 credits; ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Gemini, and Copilot; unlimited users; content recommendations and the Athena AI agent. The paid plan, Starter, is listed at $295/month and includes 3,600 credits a month (1 credit = 1 AI response) with 1-month rollover, 11 models, unlimited prompts and competitors, CSV export, content optimization agent; single language and region. The fine print on that door: Annual billing 17% off. API access and extra credits are paid add-ons with no published price. Above it sits Enterprise, quoted by sales.
A meter is a legitimate way to price variable usage — that should be said plainly. What it does is move cadence risk onto the buyer. Cadence is credit-constrained rather than fixed: 1 credit is 1 AI response, so 50 prompts on 5 engines daily is about 7,500 responses a month against the 3,600 credits Starter includes. The content side spends from the same allowance, so a month of heavy publishing leaves fewer credits for watching, and the other way round. When the pool empties: Extra credits and API access are paid add-ons on top of Starter; AthenaHQ's page says to contact them for add-on pricing.
Now run our own plans through their published meter, using their own unit — one credit per AI response. AEO Action Solo scans 100 prompts across 3 engines every day: 9,000 responses a month, which is past the 3,600 credits Starter includes — and it costs $149, flat, with nothing extra to buy when the month runs long. Solo Pro scans 200 prompts across 4 engines daily: 24,000 responses a month at $299 flat. We are not claiming AthenaHQ overcharges; a team that scans a short prompt list weekly can live well inside its allowance, and its free plan costs nothing at all. We are laying the two pricing physics side by side. One meters the checking and the writing. The other prices the job.
Row by row: the same question, both columns
Our column states what the product does today; AthenaHQ's restates its plans page and integrations docs as our dataset records them.
| Compared on | AEO Action$149–549/mo flat · self-serve | AthenaHQFree, then $295/mo on credits · enterprise custom |
|---|---|---|
| The billing model | A flat subscription — $149 Solo, $299 Solo Pro, $549 Agency (10 client projects). Daily cadence at every paid tier; the invoice does not move with usage. | A credit allowance. Essential is free and includes 300 credits; ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Gemini, and Copilot; unlimited users; content recommendations and the Athena AI agent. Starter at $295/mo includes 3,600 credits a month (1 credit = 1 AI response) with 1-month rollover, 11 models, unlimited prompts and competitors, CSV export, content optimization agent; single language and region. Extra credits and API access are paid add-ons on top of Starter; AthenaHQ's page says to contact them for add-on pricing. |
| Engines covered | Up to five — ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, and Claude. Pick 3 of 4 at $149, 4 of 5 at $299, all five on Agency. No Grok, no Copilot, and no separate Google AI Mode row. This row is AthenaHQ's. | 11 models on the $295 Starter plan: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, Copilot, Grok, DeepSeek, Meta AI, and Mistral. The free Essential plan covers 5 (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Gemini, Copilot). |
| Cadence at the entry price | Daily at every paid tier: ChatGPT and Gemini read through the live consumer interface, Perplexity via its API, AI Overviews from live Google results; Claude runs in a labeled model mode, never counted as live. | Cadence is credit-constrained rather than fixed: 1 credit is 1 AI response, so 50 prompts on 5 engines daily is about 7,500 responses a month against the 3,600 credits Starter includes. |
| Who does the work | A daily orchestrator reads the scan, picks the highest-value move, and prepares the finished artifact — schema, FAQ page, landing page, or Reddit pack — into an approve queue. Nothing publishes without your click. | Content recommendations and the Athena AI agent on the free plan; a content optimization agent on Starter. You direct the agents, and their work spends credits from the same allowance as monitoring. |
| Where approved work lands | On WordPress our plugin publishes the approved page on your own site on its hourly sync. On Webflow, Squarespace, Wix, Shopify, and custom builds the page goes live on your own subdomain or a shared pages address we host, verified live — next to your site, not inside its CMS. Approved URLs then go to IndexNow; Bing decides what to index. | A real execution loop: recommendations, a content optimization agent, and eight documented Create & Publish connections (Shopify, Webflow, Wix, Framer, WordPress, Payload CMS, Sanity, Contentful) that publish content created in Athena to the live site. Squarespace is not on the list. Everything draws on the same credit pool as monitoring. |
| Proof it moved something | Fate-tracking checks every approved landing page against its target question for up to 120 days — a dated shipped-to-cited receipt — plus a plain-English work report every 7 days, and an AEO Pixel read on assistant-referred visitors. | Tracking dashboards with CSV export on Starter and BI dashboards on Enterprise, per its plans page. Our dataset does not record a per-page shipped-to-cited receipt or an index-submission step on its side; ask AthenaHQ before assuming either way. |
| The first dollar | $0 — a free audit (10 buyer questions, 3 engines, 30 live answers, an email and no card), then a 7-day trial of the paid product, also without a card. No standing free plan. | Free Essential plan with 300 credits; no card-free trial of the paid Starter plan is advertised. |
The billing model
AEO Action
A flat subscription — $149 Solo, $299 Solo Pro, $549 Agency (10 client projects). Daily cadence at every paid tier; the invoice does not move with usage.
AthenaHQ
A credit allowance. Essential is free and includes 300 credits; ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Gemini, and Copilot; unlimited users; content recommendations and the Athena AI agent. Starter at $295/mo includes 3,600 credits a month (1 credit = 1 AI response) with 1-month rollover, 11 models, unlimited prompts and competitors, CSV export, content optimization agent; single language and region. Extra credits and API access are paid add-ons on top of Starter; AthenaHQ's page says to contact them for add-on pricing.
Engines covered
AEO Action
Up to five — ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, and Claude. Pick 3 of 4 at $149, 4 of 5 at $299, all five on Agency. No Grok, no Copilot, and no separate Google AI Mode row. This row is AthenaHQ's.
AthenaHQ
11 models on the $295 Starter plan: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, Copilot, Grok, DeepSeek, Meta AI, and Mistral. The free Essential plan covers 5 (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Gemini, Copilot).
Cadence at the entry price
AEO Action
Daily at every paid tier: ChatGPT and Gemini read through the live consumer interface, Perplexity via its API, AI Overviews from live Google results; Claude runs in a labeled model mode, never counted as live.
AthenaHQ
Cadence is credit-constrained rather than fixed: 1 credit is 1 AI response, so 50 prompts on 5 engines daily is about 7,500 responses a month against the 3,600 credits Starter includes.
Who does the work
AEO Action
A daily orchestrator reads the scan, picks the highest-value move, and prepares the finished artifact — schema, FAQ page, landing page, or Reddit pack — into an approve queue. Nothing publishes without your click.
AthenaHQ
Content recommendations and the Athena AI agent on the free plan; a content optimization agent on Starter. You direct the agents, and their work spends credits from the same allowance as monitoring.
Where approved work lands
AEO Action
On WordPress our plugin publishes the approved page on your own site on its hourly sync. On Webflow, Squarespace, Wix, Shopify, and custom builds the page goes live on your own subdomain or a shared pages address we host, verified live — next to your site, not inside its CMS. Approved URLs then go to IndexNow; Bing decides what to index.
AthenaHQ
A real execution loop: recommendations, a content optimization agent, and eight documented Create & Publish connections (Shopify, Webflow, Wix, Framer, WordPress, Payload CMS, Sanity, Contentful) that publish content created in Athena to the live site. Squarespace is not on the list. Everything draws on the same credit pool as monitoring.
Proof it moved something
AEO Action
Fate-tracking checks every approved landing page against its target question for up to 120 days — a dated shipped-to-cited receipt — plus a plain-English work report every 7 days, and an AEO Pixel read on assistant-referred visitors.
AthenaHQ
Tracking dashboards with CSV export on Starter and BI dashboards on Enterprise, per its plans page. Our dataset does not record a per-page shipped-to-cited receipt or an index-submission step on its side; ask AthenaHQ before assuming either way.
The first dollar
AEO Action
$0 — a free audit (10 buyer questions, 3 engines, 30 live answers, an email and no card), then a 7-day trial of the paid product, also without a card. No standing free plan.
AthenaHQ
Free Essential plan with 300 credits; no card-free trial of the paid Starter plan is advertised.
AthenaHQ cells verified November 2026 against athenahq.ai/plans and docs.athenahq.ai/integrations, as recorded in lib/seo/market-data.ts — what its pages list, never a claim about what it cannot do; vendors reprice and ship features. AEO Action cells state what the product does today.
When AthenaHQ is the right pick
A real share of readers should choose AthenaHQ, and not reluctantly:
- You want the content inside a CMS we do not write to. Its documented connections cover Shopify, Webflow, Wix, Framer, Payload CMS, Sanity, and Contentful as well as WordPress. Outside WordPress, our approved pages live on a subdomain or a shared pages address — real, indexable pages, but beside your site rather than in it.
- Your battleground is Google's AI surfaces. Founded by ex-Google Search product managers, it lists Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, and Gemini as separate models on Starter — a finer-grained read on the Google ecosystem than we offer, since our five engines include AI Overviews but not AI Mode.
- You need the wider lens. Grok, Copilot, DeepSeek, Meta AI, and Mistral are on its Starter list. If your buyers ask there, no flat plan of ours reaches them.
- You want to start at zero and stay there a while. The free Essential plan is a standing plan, not a trial clock. Ours is a one-time free audit and then a 7-day trial.
- False AI claims about your brand are the headline problem. 2026 reviews single out its hallucination detection; our nearest surfaces — Brand Sentiment classification and the verbatim Live AI Replay — read tone and text, not truthfulness.
- You are multi-market and headed upmarket anyway. Starter is single language and region; the Enterprise tier includes Custom credits, multi-region and multi-language, SAML/OIDC SSO, audit log, persona targeting, Athena Citation Engine (ACE), BI dashboards, white-glove setup.That tier competes with Profound's platform — a contest we map in AEO Action vs Profound — and we are not in it.
If none of those describe you, the credit meter is the thing you are actually shopping, and the wider field of options is laid out in AthenaHQ alternatives.
What the flat $149 contains
Here is the other column's full stack, so the comparison is symmetrical. Every month, at the same price:
- The daily scan — 100 tracked buyer questions, built once from your business profile and asked verbatim every run across your 3 chosen engines on their live interfaces, so results compare across time.
- The department — one specialist-prepared artifact a day (schema, FAQ page, landing page, or Reddit pack), finished and waiting in the approve queue, not a task suggestion.
- Approve → shipped — on WordPress the plugin publishes the approved page automatically, usually within the hour; on Webflow, Squarespace, Wix, and everything else the finished page goes live on your subdomain or our shared pages address and is verified live.
- Index submission — approved URLs go to IndexNow within minutes; Bing decides what to index. The mechanics live in Bing and Copilot optimization.
- Proof — a dated shipped-to-cited receipt per approved page, tracked up to 120 days, and a plain-English work report every 7 days.
Why the submission step is automated at all — a measured overlap, not a documented pipeline:
~87%
of ChatGPT's cited pages also rank in Bing's top results
Source: Seer Interactive, 2026
Read it as an outside measurement, not a mechanism: OpenAI names OAI-SearchBot as the crawler behind ChatGPT Search and does not publish which index sits behind it. We submit; Bing decides; the overlap is why the submission is worth automating.
And the anchor both products should be measured against is neither of our stickers — it is the human retainer this work otherwise costs:
$2,000–6,000
per month — AEO agency retainers, the traditional way to buy this loop
Source: 2026 market research
Both products on this page price the work below that band at their published tiers. AthenaHQ's Enterprise plan is quoted by sales, so we cannot place it against the band, and we do not guess. The buy-versus-hire math is worked through in our services teardown.
Every vendor sticker in the category, add-on math included, is in the AI visibility tool pricing table; what human retainers cover at those prices is in what AEO services actually charge.
Five buyers, judged one at a time
The brand team that lives on Google surfaces
Not us. If AI Mode, AI Overviews, and Gemini are your three battlegrounds and you want them as separate models — with Grok and Copilot on the side — AthenaHQ covers ground we do not. Buy it and budget the credits honestly.
The solo operator with no writer
Buy AEO Action Solo at $149— after trying AthenaHQ's free plan, which costs you nothing. This is the buyer the flat department exists for: one finished artifact is prepared every day without anyone directing an agent, and no credit balance decides which weeks you get to watch.
The agency with ten clients on ordinary retainers
Buy AEO Action Agency at $549: 10 client projects, daily scans on all five engines, white-label client portals, and a REST API as listed line items. The three AthenaHQ plans in our dataset — Essential, Starter, and Enterprise — are not priced per client, and Starter covers a single language and region. The margin math per client is in AEO for agencies.
The multi-market enterprise with a procurement checklist
Not us, plainly. AthenaHQ's Enterprise tier lists multi-region and multi-language tracking, SAML/OIDC single sign-on, and an audit log. We have no SOC 2, no SSO, and no multi-language scanning today. Shortlist AthenaHQ or Profound.
The team on Webflow, Wix, Shopify, or Framer
Genuinely close, and it turns on where the page must live. AthenaHQ's connections publish content created in Athena into your own CMS on all four. Ours puts the approved page on a subdomain or a shared pages address beside your site. If the work has to sit inside the site's own CMS: them. If a flat price, a page prepared for you each day, index submission, and a per-page receipt matter more than the address: us.
When not to choose AEO Action
Written by us, against ourselves, without softening — the real disqualifiers:
- You need Grok, Copilot, or Google AI Mode watched. Our five engines include none of them, nor DeepSeek, Meta AI, or Mistral. All six are on AthenaHQ's Starter list.
- You are not on WordPress and expect the page inside your site. Your approved page goes live on a subdomain or a shared pages address, schema included — real output, outside the site itself; a page inside the builder is still a paste. AthenaHQ documents direct connections to Webflow, Wix, Shopify, and Framer.
- You want a free plan that does not expire. We do not have one. AthenaHQ does.
- You need enterprise analytics depth. Persona targeting, BI dashboards, single sign-on, an audit log — that is AthenaHQ-enterprise and Profound territory, not ours.
- Hallucination detection is the job. 2026 reviews name it as an AthenaHQ feature; our nearest tools classify sentiment and replay answers verbatim, which is watching, not fact-checking.
- Nobody will open the approve queue. Publishing waits on a human by design. An untouched queue turns the department into an expensive tracker.
Switching, and what the meter leaves behind
- Credits and history stay behind. Starter credits roll over one month and then lapse, an unused allowance has no exit value, and whatever trend series either tool built stays in the tool that built it. Switch at a reporting boundary, not mid-quarter.
- Mind the billing terms on both sides. AthenaHQ's Starter terms: Annual billing 17% off. API access and extra credits are paid add-ons with no published price. An annual plan runs to term, so time a move to the renewal. Our trial takes no card at all, so there is nothing to cancel if you only wanted a look.
- Prompt sets re-express, they do not import. We build your buyer questions once from your business profile and freeze them as a tracked panel; AthenaHQ tracks the prompts you configure. The first weeks after a switch measure differently by design — in either direction.
The verdict
Judged on everything above — and knowing we sell one of the two columns:
Unhedged: buy AthenaHQ if your buyers ask across its longer engine list, if the content has to be published inside Webflow, Wix, Shopify, or Framer, or if you are a multi-market team headed for its enterprise tier anyway — and start on its free plan either way; buy AEO Action if you want one flat $149 to cover the daily scan, the page prepared for you, the approve-to-publish step, the index submission, and the dated receipt — the whole loop, with no meter to watch.
Already sure? Start the 7-day trial · The free audit runs 30 live queries in about three minutes. Just an email, no account, no card — and no credit balance to spend down.
09 · FAQ
Asked before anyone feeds a meter.
Is AEO Action an AthenaHQ alternative?
How fast do AthenaHQ credits run out?
Does AthenaHQ have a free plan or a free trial?
Which product covers more AI engines?
Can either product make an AI engine cite my business?
Keep reading
Tool comparisons
AthenaHQ alternatives
Six AthenaHQ alternatives sorted by the wall you hit, plus the honest case for staying on it.
Tool comparisons
vs Profound
Our own honest ledger — including the cases where Profound is the right call.
Costs & pricing
AI visibility tool pricing
The canonical price table: every vendor, every add-on, verified against published pricing.
Costs & pricing
AEO services
Retainer anatomy — what $2,000–6,000/month buys, when an agency is right, and the software alternative.
Read your own answers before you price anyone's meter.
Ten of your buyers' questions across ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity — 30 live answers, the three most revealing quoted word-for-word, and three moves to make, in order. It costs nothing and asks for nothing: just an email, no account, no card. Then weigh both products against what you saw.
Already sure? Start the 7-day trial · Free audit first: see exactly where you stand before paying anything. 7-day trial, no card.